Baseball is almost the only orderly thing in a very unorderly world. If you get three strikes, even the best lawyer in the world can't get you off. -- Bill Veeck
While the law cannot come to the aid of a strikeout on the diamond, it apparently can rule on the muscles behind the bats. Baseball currently stands as not only the national pastime, but the center of a steroid abuse scandal that still reverberates through the hallowed walls of the nation's baseball stadiums and the musty courtrooms of the Ninth Circuit in California. The two venues converged when the Ninth Circuit's Court of Appeals retreated from an August 2009 e-discovery ruling against government prosecutors, in an offshoot of the Bay Area Laboratory Co-Operative (BALCO) steroid abuse scandal.
In the BALCO case, government agents had search warrants for the confidential medical records of 10 baseball players. As reported in an article in Crime in the Suites, that original ruling spelled out tight controls on what methods government agents could use to review and retain electronic information seized during the BALCO criminal investigation. In the course of executing the warrants, medical records of hundreds of other players were obtained and used to obtain more search warrants. The government argued that those records came into "plain view" and thus were usable.